5. Progressions

I. Making music

Progressions

One chord after another is a progression, and most songs are a few of them, repeated. Which chords go together isn't arbitrary: each chord of a key does one of three jobs, and some moves between them happen far more often than others. This chapter names the jobs, shows the moves, and plays the progressions the studio offers, from the four chords of countless pop songs to the blues and the Andalusian cadence. Then it steps outside the key.

zig build run-studio -- manual/05-progressions/cadence

Home, away, and tension

The chords of a key fall into three families by what they do:

Job Major key Minor key Sounds like
home I, iii, vi i, III, VI at rest: the music could stop
away ii, IV ii°, iv moving off, going somewhere
tension V, vii° v, VII leaning hard, wanting home

The chord list marks each of the key's chords with its job, and the hint over a chord on the row names it: IV F: away from home, moving. Usually goes to I, V, ii. The three chords that share notes with the tonic chord feel like home; the two built on 4 and 2 move away; and the two that hold the leading note, V and vii°, pull back. A progression that goes home, away, tension, and home again tells a whole small story, and it's called a cadence.

I IV V7 I in C major: C, F, G7, and C, with a piano and a bass following the chord row. Listen for the G7 leaning, and the last C landing.: the arrange

0.0 / 10.7 s

peak -14.1 dBFS

Fig. 5.1 I IV V7 I in C major: C, F, G7, and C, with a piano and a bass following the chord row. Listen for the G7 leaning, and the last C landing.

openzig build run-studio -- manual/05-progressions/cadence

renderzig build run-studio -- render manual/05-progressions/cadence cadence.wav

cadence/song.json
{
  "tempo": 90,
  "end": "5",
  "key": ["1 C major"],
  "chords": ["1 C", "2 F", "3 G7", "4 C"],
  "devices": [
    { "name": "synth", "type": "synth", "state": { "parts": [
      { "patch": "A45", "level": -2, "reverb_send": 15 },
      { "patch": "A52", "level": -6 }
    ] } }
  ],
  "tracks": [
    { "name": "piano", "device": "synth", "channel": 1, "keys": "chord", "role": "chords", "clips": [{ "at": "1", "length": "4.0.0", "notes": "piano" }] },
    { "name": "bass", "device": "synth", "channel": 2, "keys": "pent", "role": "bass", "clips": [{ "at": "1", "length": "4.0.0", "notes": "bass" }] }
  ],
  "notes": {
    "piano": { "length": "4.0.0", "follow": { "pattern": "halves", "low": "F3" } },
    "bass": { "length": "4.0.0", "follow": { "pattern": "roots", "low": "E1" } }
  }
}

The piano and the bass here hold no notes of their own. They make them from the chord row, as chapter 6 shows, so changing a chord on the row changes both.

What follows what

Any chord can follow any other, but some moves are so common they sound like the natural way to go. The chord list marks, with a ›, the chords that most often follow the one before, after the chart of normal progressions in Stefan Kostka and Dorothy Payne's Tonal Harmony, with the moves pop adds, which Hooktheory's analysis of over a thousand songs shows:

From In major, usually to From In minor, usually to
I IV, V, vi i iv, VI, VII
ii V, vii°, IV ii° v, i
iii vi, IV III VI, iv, VII
IV I, V, ii iv v, i, VII
V I, vi, IV v i, VI, iv
vi IV, ii, V VI VII, iv, III
vii° I, iii VII III, i, VI

I goes anywhere. Classical harmony runs from home through away to tension and home, iii to vi to ii or IV to V to I; pop adds IV going straight home, as often as V does.

The progressions

progression, in the chord row's menu, which chords ▾ over the track list drops, opens a list of progressions to lay over the bars of the section selected, or between the locators: a chord a bar, repeated to fill them. As with every list, Up and Down try each one while the song plays, and Enter writes it as one edit. A progression is written in its own mode's numerals, and in a song of the other mode it plays from the relative key: the axis in A minor is C, G, Am, and F, the same chords.

Progression Numerals What it does Heard in
axis I V vi IV Home, away, a turn to minor, and back: four chords for countless songs "Let It Be", "Don't Stop Believin'"
axis from its minor vi IV I V The same chords started on the relative minor, so they sound sadder "Zombie"
doo-wop I vi IV V The 1950s turn, its bass falling in thirds "Stand by Me"
three chords I IV V IV Rock and roll's vocabulary, rocking between the two chords away "Wild Thing"
twelve-bar blues I7 I7 I7 I7 IV7 IV7 I7 I7 V7 IV7 I7 V7 The blues, in dominant sevenths "Johnny B. Goode"
two-five-one ii7 V7 Imaj7 Imaj7 Jazz's cadence: away, tension, home "Autumn Leaves"
canon I V vi iii IV I IV V Pachelbel's eight chords, each pair a step below the last Pachelbel's Canon
royal road IV V iii vi J-pop's favorite, which never lands on I
mixolydian I bVII IV I A major key with a flat 7th, rock's open-string sound "Sweet Home Alabama"
borrowed iv I III IV iv A major chord turned minor, the classic lump in the throat "Creep"
aeolian loop i VI III VII Natural minor, all the way round, without a leading note
andalusian i VII VI V A minor scale falling to a major V "Hit the Road Jack"
minor cadence i iv V i Minor, with the harmonic minor's V pulling home
dorian vamp i IV Minor with a major IV: two chords, open-ended "Oye Como Va"
house vamp i7 iv7 Two minor sevenths, for stabs and long pads
deep house i9 iv9 VImaj7 v7 The two-loop walkthrough's kind of loop
one chord i Techno's way: the change is in the sound, not the harmony

The words are the list's own, and its hints'. The axis is the one to know first:

The axis, I V vi IV in C major: C, G, Am, and F, on a piano playing a ballad's broken chords and a pad holding them.: the chords

0.0 / 12.0 s

peak -17.0 dBFS

Fig. 5.2 The axis, I V vi IV in C major: C, G, Am, and F, on a piano playing a ballad's broken chords and a pad holding them.

openzig build run-studio -- manual/05-progressions/axis

renderzig build run-studio -- render manual/05-progressions/axis axis.wav

axis/song.json
{
  "tempo": 80,
  "end": "5",
  "key": ["1 C major"],
  "chords": ["1 C", "2 G", "3 Am", "4 F"],
  "devices": [
    { "name": "synth", "type": "synth", "state": { "parts": [
      { "patch": "A45", "level": 2, "reverb_send": 20 },
      { "patch": "A31", "level": -6, "reverb_send": 25 }
    ] } }
  ],
  "tracks": [
    { "name": "piano", "device": "synth", "channel": 1, "keys": "chord 7 bass", "role": "chords", "clips": [{ "at": "1", "length": "4.0.0", "notes": "piano" }] },
    { "name": "pad", "device": "synth", "channel": 2, "keys": "chord 7", "role": "pad", "clips": [{ "at": "1", "length": "4.0.0", "notes": "pad" }] }
  ],
  "notes": {
    "piano": { "length": "4.0.0", "follow": { "pattern": "broken", "low": "D2" } },
    "pad": { "length": "4.0.0", "follow": { "pattern": "whole", "low": "F3" } }
  }
}

Home, then tension that doesn't resolve, then the relative minor, then away, and round again: the loop never quite lands, which is why it can repeat for a whole song. Start the same four chords on vi, Am F C G, and it's the axis from its minor, the same notes in a sadder order.

The Andalusian cadence in A minor: Am, G, F, and E, each a step below the last. The E is outlined on the row: its G# isn't in A minor.: the chords

0.0 / 9.6 s

peak -13.9 dBFS

Fig. 5.3 The Andalusian cadence in A minor: Am, G, F, and E, each a step below the last. The E is outlined on the row: its G# isn't in A minor.

openzig build run-studio -- manual/05-progressions/andalusian

renderzig build run-studio -- render manual/05-progressions/andalusian andalusian.wav

andalusian/song.json
{
  "tempo": 100,
  "end": "5",
  "key": ["1 A minor"],
  "chords": ["1 Am", "2 G", "3 F", "4 E"],
  "devices": [
    { "name": "synth", "type": "synth", "state": { "parts": [
      { "patch": "A45", "level": -2, "reverb_send": 15 },
      { "patch": "A52", "level": -6 }
    ] } }
  ],
  "tracks": [
    { "name": "piano", "device": "synth", "channel": 1, "keys": "chord", "role": "chords", "clips": [{ "at": "1", "length": "4.0.0", "notes": "piano" }] },
    { "name": "bass", "device": "synth", "channel": 2, "keys": "pent", "role": "bass", "clips": [{ "at": "1", "length": "4.0.0", "notes": "bass" }] }
  ],
  "notes": {
    "piano": { "length": "4.0.0", "follow": { "pattern": "pulse", "low": "F3" } },
    "bass": { "length": "4.0.0", "follow": { "pattern": "root five", "low": "E1" } }
  }
}

The bass walks down A, G, F, E, and the last chord is major, though natural minor would make it Em. That E major is the harmonic minor's V, with the 7th of the scale raised a semitone to G#, a leading note that pulls up to A and home again. It's the cadence flamenco is built on.

Borrowing

A song can take a chord from outside its key, and the chord row outlines it, so you see where the music leaves home. The chord list offers two kinds under borrowed and dominants:

  • Borrowed chords come from the parallel key, the one with the same tonic and the other mode. A major key borrows iv, ♭VI, and ♭VII from its minor, and a minor key borrows IV and V7 from its major. In C major: Fm, Ab, and Bb. The Y color key in chapter 4 plays them under one finger.
  • Dominants of the degrees lead into a chord other than home. V7/vi, "five of six", is the dominant seventh a fifth above vi: E7, which pulls into Am in C major as G7 pulls into C. The U color key plays them.
I III IV iv in C major: C, E, F, and Fm. E and Fm are outlined on the row; the last chord turns F minor for a bar.: the arrange

0.0 / 10.4 s

peak -13.5 dBFS

Fig. 5.4 I III IV iv in C major: C, E, F, and Fm. E and Fm are outlined on the row; the last chord turns F minor for a bar.

openzig build run-studio -- manual/05-progressions/borrowed

renderzig build run-studio -- render manual/05-progressions/borrowed borrowed.wav

borrowed/song.json
{
  "tempo": 92,
  "end": "5",
  "key": ["1 C major"],
  "chords": ["1 C", "2 E", "3 F", "4 Fm"],
  "devices": [
    { "name": "synth", "type": "synth", "state": { "parts": [
      { "patch": "A45", "level": -2, "reverb_send": 20 },
      { "patch": "A52", "level": -6 }
    ] } }
  ],
  "tracks": [
    { "name": "piano", "device": "synth", "channel": 1, "keys": "chord", "role": "chords", "clips": [{ "at": "1", "length": "4.0.0", "notes": "piano" }] },
    { "name": "bass", "device": "synth", "channel": 2, "keys": "pent", "role": "bass", "clips": [{ "at": "1", "length": "4.0.0", "notes": "bass" }] }
  ],
  "notes": {
    "piano": { "length": "4.0.0", "follow": { "pattern": "halves", "low": "F3" } },
    "bass": { "length": "4.0.0", "follow": { "pattern": "roots", "low": "E1" } }
  }
}

E major here is the dominant of vi, and F minor is borrowed from C minor: the same F chord, with its A lowered to Ab. That one semitone, the major chord turning minor, is the lump in the throat the list's line names.

Try it in the window

  • Open the cadence song and click its G7 on the chord row. Step through the chord list while the song plays: try ii, IV, and vii° in its place.
  • Select bars with the locators, choose progression from chords ▾, and step through every progression, listening to each over the same bass.
  • In the axis song, change C major to A minor in the key list, in the bar, and turn on I ii: the numerals change to III VII i VI, and the chords stay.
  • Click the last chord of the borrowed song and choose ♭VII from the list instead of iv.
  • Rest the pointer on each chord of the andalusian row and read its hint.

Next: chapter 6, bass lines, the first part that plays from the chords.